Erin and Kyle met at the University of Arizona where they both worked as baristas at their university's Starbucks. Erin and Kyle began dating at the end of their senior year of college. Shortly after they moved into their apartment in Tucson, Arizona where they adopted Blue and Pippa. In the summer of 2019, Erin and Kyle moved to New York City. After four years of dating, Erin and Kyle finally traveled abroad together to France where Kyle proposed to Erin in Marseille.